Sustaining water resources is a primary issue facing Florida Extension. The study reported here identified how experience with water issues and familiarity with water policies affected individuals’ engagement in water conservation behaviors. A public opinion survey was conducted online to capture Florida residents’ responses. The findings indicated experience with water issues and familiarity with water policies were predictors of individuals’ engagement in civic water conservation behaviors. Given this, Extension educators developing programs and educational materials about water conservation behaviors should cover information related to water policies because participants will be more inclined to engage if they are familiar with policies.